Field Notes from The Expanded Environment: Towards a Practice of Critical Non-Human Design

While recently presenting on a Speculative Design Panel at the Annual Society for Science Literature and the Arts conference, I was posed with the question “who are the beneficiaries of non-human design?”  I retorted– who are the beneficiaries of an ecosystem?  Perhaps, if we reconsider designing with the non-human first, within the context of mass extinction and runaway climate change, the dispersed idea of beneficiary design would think of the whole of an ecosystem that will in turn benefit humans as well.

Yet it is not simply a point of considering the non-human.  Of course for instance– at the development of the steam engine, non-human forces were considered in a context of efficiency, energy, and the economy.  To think the Non-Human aspect of design one must think through the fundamental ideas of what define architecture as a practice enmeshed within larger ecologies and geological temporality.  The history and context of natural systems must be considered within the histories of labor and capitalist production.  To think critically about design as the contraction between these two spheres, that is the true task of Non-Human Design.

For example, Biophilic Design, or even Animal Architectures, offer great examples as attempts to think critically about Non-Human Design.  Yet these practices more often than not are situated as attempts to capitalize on feigned notions of sustainability.  Sustainability discourse is centered around the idea of ecological homeostasis.  Yet the paradoxes of the Anthropocene (mass extinction yet an explosion of human population) prove that without a critique of capitalism and political economy, Political Ecology will only amount to reactionary, after-the-fact responses to a nostalgic conception of the past.  Worse still, in Biophilic design and Animal Architectures, the designer still upholds a client-clientele relation, merely recentering the Anthropos as an agent of economic transaction.  Biophilic design principals use symbolic functions that persist in nature, which provide a framework for understanding and enabling thoughtful incorporation of a rich diversity of strategies into the built environment.  Biomimicry is often hailed as a panacea to sustainability issues, yet mimesis is not enough.  The example Temple Grandin’s sympathetic design of slaughterhouses, despite its attention to so-called humane slaughter, is still organized around for-profit, biopolitical end goals of enclosure, slaughter, consumption and profit.

In McKenzie Wark’s recent article in E-Flux– From Architecture to Kainotecture… The media theorist attempts to postulate an architecture for the Anthropocene.  As the Anthropocene forces important questions regarding the position of the human within earth processes, some of the most interesting work within architecture is attempting to shift the point of view of world building from human habitation to more-than-human cohabitation.  Kainotecture for Wark would be an architecture for an unpredictable world.  Prepared for any contingency and thought of as a mediator between the Human-At-Risk and the Non-Human as an ambiguous threat.  However, architecture is not merely situated at the simple impasse of nature vs. culture. Kainotecture embraces frailty and aims for an architecture of the entire ecological situation, not just human self-defense.

So, to roughly sketch out a program for Non-Human Design, we must schematically counter-act the folly of either focusing only on capitalist production or ‘natural histories.’  To counter these shortsited efforts of Biophilia, Sustainable Architectures, and Animal Architectures, which still uphold for-profit models of design-labor, my claim is that we must address three key areas of the design process– non human temporality and materiality, de-centered perspectives of social-environmental relations, and the feedback loop between Non-Human centric design practices into human economies.

1.  Non Human Temporality and Materiality

Much of the damage leftover from profit laden development and design has been from a focus on the human as a self-centered and competitive being.  The temporal scale of architecture has largely focused on the use-value of the time scale of genealogy and generations.  Yet with the advent of the Anthropocene we see this with chemical leaching of construction materials, interior energy systems scaling up to produce greenhouse emissions, and downstream effects of micro-plastics and micro-toxicity.  And even when architecture must re-imagine itself, this is usually within the context of crisis (either local or global) to fulfill a new economic model.

As for my own practice, within Adaptive Reuse, it is useful to think of the gaps in temporality left behind by certain discreet modes of production.  For instance, in an urban environment, a certain mode of production may be dominant for some time only to lose out to competition from elsewhere.  This can leave behind infrastructures of disuse where the value of the property will plummet until there is a rent gap between the actual value of the land (as potential development) and what is on the land (as something to be repurposed). This creates a hotspot for urban development when the rent gap becomes enticing to investors.

I find the Farm Sanctuary movement an interesting intervention within the temporality of factory farming.  My site specific work with the Farm Sanctuary in Watkins Glen thinks through the biopolitical lifespan of a farm animal as property, through a transition into being the subject of human care and protection.  Mediating this transition through architectures designed not for human concerns yet repurposing existing materials left over from previous modes of capitalist production creates an interesting set of problems for Non-Human Design.  

To consider the other forms of life without an incentive to create profit margins off of their objectification is an example of considering non-human temporality and materiality.

2.  Decentered Perspectives of Social-Environmental Relations

The double-bind of thinking the Non-Human is that, of course, we are always considering this impossibility from the perspective of the human.  So what perspectives would allow us to at least glimpse, or come close to considering the welfare of Non-Human Animals.  In this case, Animal Ethology and Veterinary Medicine offer perspectives to shift the focus from the human abstraction of living systems (as resources) to thinking life systems from an objective and compassionate viewpoint.  Biophilia may, for instance, use mimicry of life sciences to produce aesthetic objects, architectural form, or even interventions within micro-scale living systems, yet the danger is merely using scientific knowledge for the end of aesthetic consumption.  I would like to think a Non-Human design without the traditional conception of aesthetic value.

3. Downstream Effects of Non-Human Design 

Now to return to a model of design as holistically beneficial.  To fully consider the Non-Human temporalities of materials and Non-Human timelines would have long term down-stream effects.  We must understand every process of design as designing with Non-Human forces.  To refuse a homeostatic model of ecology not as a closed system but as open to change and adaptation.  This is not to say that ecological diversity and well being are not central concerns to Non-Human design, they of course are paramount.  The understanding of design in the manner of the Non-Human should be able to operate at the intersection of energetic systems that exceed the building as such, as well as informational systems and economics.  If the Anthropocene hypothesis unifies natural history with histories of capitalism… then creating new economies out of design imperatives, creating new modes of doing the least amount of harm by introducing or repurposing materials for Non-Human life should be a central concern for Architects in these uncertain times.  The true success of architecture then would not be its lasting symbolic value but its de-centered use-value for all life on earth.